Christa Pike, the only woman on Tennessee’s death row, is scheduled to be executed by lethal injection on September 30 at Riverbend Maximum Security Institution in Nashville.

Pike, now 50, was sentenced to death for the 1995 murder of 19-year-old Colleen Slemmer, whom prosecutors said she and two other teenagers lured to a secluded area and attacked.

Pike was 18 when the crime took place. If the execution goes ahead, she would be the first woman executed in Tennessee since 1819 and the first person in the state’s modern death penalty era to be executed for a crime committed at exactly age 18.

Also Read | Europe’s seas are getting warmer. Its fishermen are seeing the consequences

A firm verdict

Pike’s execution remains scheduled for September 30 after the court denied her latest request for a stay | X (@TheLinzerShow)
ZOOM IMAGE
Pike’s execution remains scheduled for September 30 after the court denied her latest request for a stay | X (@TheLinzerShow)

The central issue now is not whether Pike was convicted. She was convicted in 1996 of murder and conspiracy to commit murder and sentenced to death.

The dispute is about whether factors surrounding her life and the execution itself should change that outcome.

Her lawyers have presented evidence of severe childhood abuse, sexual violence and neglect. Court records say Pike was sexually assaulted as a child and later diagnosed with PTSD and bipolar disorder.

Her defence also argues that important mitigating evidence was not properly presented to the original jury. Pike has since expressed remorse for Slemmer’s death.

“I feel remarkably remorseful for what I did,” she said in a documentary about her case.

The line at 18

Age adds another layer to the case. In 2005, the US Supreme Court ruled in Roper v. Simmons that the death penalty cannot be imposed for crimes committed by people who were under 18.

The court pointed to differences in maturity, judgment and vulnerability between juveniles and adults.

Pike cannot invoke the Supreme Court's juvenile death penalty ban because she was 18 | X (@XAmericanValues)
ZOOM IMAGE
Pike cannot invoke the Supreme Court’s juvenile death penalty ban because she was 18 | X (@XAmericanValues)

Pike, however, was 18 at the time of Slemmer’s murder, so that categorical constitutional protection does not apply to her. Her lawyers instead argue that modern understanding of adolescent brain development and the long-term effects of childhood trauma should be considered as mitigating factors.

That argument has also featured in recent expert and legal appeals seeking to prevent her execution.

Trauma

Could the circumstances of an 18-year-old still matter decades later? | X (@901Lulu)
ZOOM IMAGE
Could the circumstances of an 18-year-old still matter decades later? | X (@901Lulu)

There is also a separate challenge over how the execution could affect Pike. Her lawyers argued that being restrained, observed by male staff and undergoing IV procedures could trigger memories of the sexual assaults she experienced as a child.

Experts and advocates have raised concerns about possible re-traumatisation.

Pike has asked for an all-female execution team. Tennessee officials have agreed to several accommodations, including female officers for her transfer where possible, privacy protections and access to her spiritual adviser before the execution.

The Tennessee Supreme Court rejected her request for a stay on September 23, finding that she had not shown the lethal-injection procedure would cause unconstitutional suffering.

Her lawyers subsequently filed an emergency application with the US Supreme Court on September 25.

The execution date remains set for September 30, subject to any further court or executive action.

Also Read | 800,000 gather for Pope Leo XIV in Paris as France confronts its Catholic roots